Melinda Doolittle sang “Sway” in recording-quality fashion. However flawless her vocals were, Simon hit her with the "you-look-older" comment. I say it's because it's an old-song-soundin'-tune, everyone will look older singing it even Michael Buble. Randy Jackson said “I’m telling you, another solid performance.” Paula Abdul said “Very, very sultry. Very smooth.” Simon Cowell said “Well, it had to happen, Melinda, I didn’t like it. I’ll tell you why because that song is all about personality, and you appeared much, much older than you are.” Melinda answered Simon's comments by saying “I’m happy, because I think he really wanted to say something bad, and I’m glad he got the chance.” Watch Melinda's performance after the jump...