Erika Van Pelt sings "New York State of Mind" during the American Idol Season 11 Top 10 show.

The verdict:

Randy Jackson: “I love the look. It is so different. I love the vocals. I think you are one of the best singers this season. Very very nice.”

Steven Tyler: “You could have put more character in it but it was outstanding.”

Jennifer Lopez: “It was such a beautiful vocal. I love the hair too. I would love to see you let loose more.”

Watch the video here: